Showing posts with label Recession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recession. Show all posts

Monday, 4 April 2011

A more formal City?

I spend quite a lot of time walking in the City of London from meeting to meeting or to my office. In the last few months, I'm much more aware of men wearing ties than I was before. My feeling is that, as times have been tough, City workers are turning to more formal dress in the office - and that fewer men are going with the 'suit and no tie' combination (that seems to be the consultants' uniform).

Looking to see if I could find evidence of this, I could only find some 'research' from 2008. I am wary of the term research because all of the statistics seemed to come from garment sellers. Remembering that caveat, however, Moss Bros reported (as reported in the Independent) that tie sales were rising at their fastest rate for five years.

The same report used the phrase "scruffy people are the first to be sacked...". While I doubt there is any science in that statement at all, I can see the sense of it. A scruffy employee gives the impression that he or she does not care - and it is that, rather than any concerns about their dress sense, that will get them to the front of the redundancy list.

So - to return to my survey of City people. I do believe that the City is a little smarter than it was. I have more clients now who wear ties than I did last year (although that, of course, might well be a reflection on a slightly changing client base). Personally I welcome it. I like to see smartly dressed people as I walk in The City. Perhaps, however, I'm just getting old...

Tuesday, 10 November 2009

Growth in a Downturn - Revenue or Cost Driven?


It's results time again, when the legal press focus in minute detail on short-term results - thereby increasing lawyers' focus on results in the last 3 months, 6 months or 12 months, all of which are too short term.

The news this time round is continuing revenue falls in some of the big players, headed up by Simmons who posted a 16% fall in revenues (see the full story here). A&O also show a fall - Norton Rose and Lovells are expecting flat results. All of these firms have been cost cutting, and it will be interesting to read the results of the mid tier firms where cost cutting has been the most savage. The evidence would seem to suggest that cost cutting hasn't helped enough - or perhaps they will suggest that it was going to be much worse. By focussing on cost cutting, some firms will have dropped the ball with regard to business development, which, I suggest, is the real way out of the downturn.

It's not been all bad news. Dentons posted a 3.5% rise in revenue in the same period (see here) - for which they thanked not savage cost cutting, but rises in international revenues.

The message has always been - the best way out of a downturn is a focus on revenues not on const-cutting. This article gives an interesting take, and sums up by saying "...do not sacrifice the future [by one-shot cost reducing savagery]" and encouraging firms to concentrate on cash efficiency and revenue growth. In another part of the same article, the author tells firms not to retreat - no matter the temptation, do not hide from the storm, but instead aim to work hard to grow your revenues. The author quotes a Harvard Business Review article which states:
Of the firms that made major gains in revenue or profitability during the last recession, more than 70% sustained those gains through the next boom cycle. The corollary was also true: fewer than 30% of those that lost ground were able to regain their positions.

Growth in a downturn is driven by revenue, not by cost cutting. I am not suggesting that any firm should ignore costs. Have a sensible policy to manage costs sensibly - but have the lawyers doing what they do best which is to provide high quality business advice, manage their clients, find new clients and find new work. Costs are important, and client & matter partners must have a very good understanding of their costs in order to be sure that their work is profitable - but their responsibility is to drive forward the revenue side of profit, while letting the managers of the business manage the cost side of profit.

Manage the costs, but work for the revenue - it's the only way forward.

Friday, 11 September 2009

The Cost of Redundancy

"The Lawyer" has a report today on Evershed's latest round of redundancies (see here for the article). Apparently they are looking to shed 22 people from their Real Estate practise offices.

Regular readers of this blog (and I'm delighted to know that there are some) will know that I have a pet topic of "knee-jerk" management and short-term thinking. I think I've stated before that law firm partners tend to like redundancy as a reaction to poor results or difficult times because it's easy to understand and a visible action on behalf of the firm (the "look - we're doing something" school of management).

It was very interesting, therefore, to read a report from the Chartered Institute of Personnel & Development (CIPD) titled "False Economy? The cost to employers of redundancy". It it an good, if technical, read and includes the formula: CR = nR + xH + xT + ny(H+T) + Wz(P-n) to find the true cost of redundancy by examining such variables as the number of people to be made redundancy, the redundancy payments, number of people subsequently hired, the hiring cost etc etc.

The key point for law firms is the cost of re-hiring people. This article reports a survey which found that it was cheaper to keep a lawyer inactive for 15 months than to fire and rehire. This will obviously depend on the level (and so cost) of the lawyer in question - but does not take into account the increased cost (through ineffectiveness) of of training a lawyer in the way the firm works, nor does it account for issues of staff morale.

The CIPD article ends with a comment that more firms (by which it means commercial firms rather than law firms) have been using methods other than redundancy such as reduced working, flexible working allowing for natural wastage and recruitment freezes to cut expenditure. They may have been doing this partly because they understand the cost of redundancy - but also because they have fewer "spare" staff.

I suspect that most law firms have now rid themselves of any spare staff who may have been hanging around. Care must now be taken to ensure that a proper analysis of all the costs is done to ensure that firms do not go through the damaging exercise of redundancy only to find that, within a short period (say 15 months), they need to rehire staff.

There is a danger that partners find that, rather than saving money, redundancy increases costs this year and re-hiring increases costs next year. There is another possibility - that by having a comparatively savage redundancy policy, re-hiring costs are greatly increased in subsequent years - when the good times return (as they inevitably will) staff jump ship to an employer who demonstrated staff-care.

"Our staff are our greatest asset"...

Thursday, 10 September 2009

Recession - Pick your Shape


Is the recession over? There has been a great deal of discussion lately about "coming out of recession" with sides being taken on the basis of (a) whether the recession is ending and (b) what shape it is or has been.

The BBC have an interesting time line on their web site today which shows the DOW and FTSE100 since 2007 (click on the graphic above to see a larger version or click here to go to the BBC's interactive version). The "shape" discussions have been may and various - I use Nouriel Roubini (I've put a link to one version of his opinion - there are many), Dan Hamilton and Lord Mandleson. They talk about a "double dip" recession - where the current upturn is the middle of the "W" shape. Other analysts see different shapes and have different views of where the economy is going. There are "U" shape economists, "V" shape economists and the those of the "it's all rather complicated and I'd prefer not to make a prediction" school (who are possibly the most sensible).

Looking at the picture above, I can see a W - but then I can see a "V" and and "U" as well. Given how much the markets can be dominated by sentiment and by confidence, I think that we would all be sensible to see a cautious recovery in place. The important thing is not the shape of the recession - it is in understanding and taking responsibility for the causes of the recession. As a group of economies, all countries should try to learn the lessons of the past and make sure that this type of recession doesn't happen again, and that we are in reasonable shape to survive a different kind of future recession, as Alan Greenspan precdicts.

Think positive - it not only helps you, but it might just help the economic recovery.

Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Flexible Working

Cobbetts were in the UK legal press (or the English legal press to be pedantic) today with an announcement of a four day week in some of its work groups - see here for the story from "The Lawyer".

In general I believe that this is a much more sensible attitude to a downturn in business that the wholesale redundancy programmes preferred by some. I suspect that it is a indication that the recession has lasted longer than Cobbetts thought and that they have divested themselves of most of those who were already on some sort of list - either because their billing was not up to scratch or they were on some other way difficult to work with - and so now they are faced with people they really want to keep.

Cobbetts are to be congratulated for doing this, as are other firms who have gone down the same road. They are also to be congratulated for doing it publicly.

The sign of the really enlightened firm would be one who introduced this sort of flexible working ("we're doing this because we value the people who work for us..." said Michael Shaw, the Managing Partner at Cobbetts) when times were good - then there would be no doubt that they really valued their people.

Wishful thinking, perhaps.

Wednesday, 10 June 2009

Confidence, Trust and the Way Forward

I've just come from a morning lecture by Lord Digby Jones. He spoke very well (of course) and shared his enthusiasm for Britain as a trading nation.

Amongst his other points, two in particular are sticking with me. He spoke about confidence and in the British (or I would say more English) reserve which stops us celebrating success. In these turbulent times, success is more important than ever - as is the knowledge of that success. To paraphrase Lord Jones - if you've had a success then shout about it. Tell everyone. He spoke about ringing the BBC to suggest that they go to see three businesses which were doing well in this recession. Sadly the BBC were "too busy". Good news rarely sells.

My other immediate take away was on the subject of trust. In response to a question on the subject, he told us that Britain still had a high reputation of trust and integrity - notwithstanding the current debacle concerning our MPs. Trust is everything. Do what you say you will and do nothing which you fear being published. Sounds simple doesn't it.

Tuesday, 28 April 2009

News, information, data and decisions

I have been looking with interest at the way that the various news agencies have been reporting the Mexican flu outbreak. Let me give you a few examples:

The deadly swine flu virus can no longer be contained, says a WHO official, as the health agency raises its alert level - from the BBC's UK News main page, Tuesday 28/04/09

The first British victims of swine flu were named today as Scottish newlyweds Iain and Dawn Askham, from Falkirk. They flew back from Cancun in Mexico last week. - Daily Mail, 28/04/09

World Health Organisation raises threat level posed by disease to unprecedented 4 as the first cases emerge in Britain - The Times, 28/09/09

First UK swine flu cases confirmed. Pandemic worries dent stock markets - Financial Times, 28/04/09

From reading these headlines - and I have deliberately only taken the headlines at the moment, it would appear that we could all well be at danger from a pandemic the size of that in 1918 which killed tens of millions.

Those were the news agencies - now let's try to dig a little deeper. Actually it's not hard. A more careful read of the items above does give a slightly different picture:

Two quotes from today's FT - Professor Neil Ferguson, a member of the WHO’s pandemic influenza taskforce, said 40 per cent of the UK population could eventually be infected if the country was hit by a pandemic.

Prof Ferguson, of London’s Imperial College, said cases were likely to die down within a matter of weeks because the UK was moving out of the normal season for flu infection, but there was a risk that the disease would flare up again once the summer was over.

He told the BBC Radio 4 Today programme the 152 deaths in Mexico probably made up a relatively small proportion of the total number infected, who might run into tens or hundreds of thousands.

“So-called bird flu - H5N1 - was a much more dangerous virus,’’ he said. “We are not in the same ballpark. But we can’t at the moment answer the question ’Is it comparable to 1918 Spanish flu, which killed a lot of people, or is it much more like Hong Kong flu?’.’’

and...

Alan Johnson, health secretary, said the UK had “established a stockpile of enough anti-viral drugs to treat more than 33m people,” or more than half the population.

I'm not sure what the opposite of alarmist is, but that would describe me. Thirty-two million people in the UK? I believe there are two reported cases at present, both of whom were in the affected area in Mexico and both of whom are responding well to treatment. That sounds a lot less alarming than describing people responding to drugs as "victims" which, perhaps only to me, implies death.

I decided to go to the source - the World Heath Organisations site. I was concerned about the threat level referred to in the "Times" and wanted to understand the scales used. I found this great graphic (see here):

Now, level 4 does look a little scary. The full text of the release from the WHO, however, stressed that the move to phase 5 was as likely as a return to phase 3 or below. The important thing I learnt from a short period of research is this: it is too early to state the extent of the outbreak.

It is a modern malaise that information is demanded so quickly. Compare the news of a flu outbreak with the on-going story of the recession. "A flu outbreak - my God. It could be pandemic. Is it pandemic - is it, is it?" we demand of scientist through our media, just as we did (and continue to do) regarding the recession "Is it worse. It's over, isn't it. House prices have gone up - we're all safe. The recession will just get worse" and so on and on. I'll repeat - it is too early to say. Both about a possible pandemic and the recession. One of the main drivers is the negative question. No credible scientist of any flavour can respond to the question "So - will you confirm that this is not a pandemic?" with anything other than a bland answer. No-one would ever say "yes" to that question because it is too early to know. Everyone knows it is too early, and yet we continue to ask. Journalists and reporters will even preface their questions with "It will be too early to say, but..."

This demand for early information and early action can be seen in business too. I spoke with a client the other day and, over a very pleasant lunch, discussed the recession and actions his firm could take. Over a particularly fine glass of wine, I explained my theory about the dangers of precipitate action and the need for good information. He generally agreed with me and then laughed and said "But you couldn't say that - either as a consultant or a CEO". I know what he meant. Organisations generally call on consultants for action and advice (or to take the blame for decisions, but that may be a different entry) and so advice consisting of "do nothing too serious yet and let's get more and better information" is unlikely to go down too well.

It is important to remember, however, that a decision based on quality information will be a quality decision. I acknowledge that one can never have perfect data and that most business decisions have to be made with a deadline in mind. Wait where possible is my message of the day.

Tuesday, 3 March 2009

Blame 2 - this time it's personal

I promise to stop going on about this soon... Well, as soon as the press calm down about looking to attribute blame for the current economic circumstances (I refuse to call it a crisis) - which is not likely to be very soon.

This time it's Robert Peston (yes, him again) writing in his blog on the BBC's web site. Writing about HBOS's results (which are awful - but who is surprised) he says:
As I've said before, it is amazing that the Financial Services Authority, the
City watchdog, didn't feel it was appropriate to rein in HBOS's corporate
lending department.

Well - as I've said before, it is amazing that the shareholders didn't feel it was appropriate to rein in HBOS's lending department. Surely they are the first line of defence? Or how about the Board - or the Non Execs?

It would not have been easy. Try to imagine suggesting dumping and running from the Sub Prime market (and its associated off-shoots) in, say, January 2006. As a Chief Executive of any global banking setup you would first have been laughed at, and second would have been fired as your stock price didn't keep pace with your competition. It can't however, all be the fault of the FSA.

Update: 
Mr. Peston is at it again - with another rant against Sir Fred Goodwin. I don't suggest that he's blameless, nor that he should avoid any form of personal permanent inconvenience for some of his decisions. What concerns me is the focus on one man - Mr. Brown and friends must be very happy. The more focus on Sir Fred, the less on them. Come on BBC - context please.

Friday, 27 February 2009

Let's blame... the Bankers

Wouldn't it be great to be able to blame the meltdown/recession/depression/economic cock-up (select your favourite) on one person or one group of people? To have one face to throw things at and to be able to curse fluently at the right person. That would be great.

Sadly I don't think it's that simple. Do I think that the Bankers were stupid or even complicit? Yes - certainly. There are, however, other people to blame too - us. The shareholders. "Wait", you say. "I wasn't a shareholder". Well if you have a pension (and if you don't, that's pretty worrying), you probably were a shareholder. I was. So at best, I too was complicit in the risk-taking that was going. After all, we the shareholders were demanding high returns - double digit growth(!) - from a mature bank. Now come on - we're all intelligent people and we know that high return demands high (or at least higher) risk. We the shareholders were demanding high returns and were willing to look the other way when confronted with the obvious increase in risk.

Shame on all of us, I say.

Will it change? No, probably not. I imagine that we, as a nation and as a group of investors, will be more cautious in the future. In the end, however, we are a greedy race. My point is that while it's fun to shout and throw things at the bankers (I'm not suggesting that we stop) - we can't wash our hands of all blame. We should examine our own positions and our own demands and accept our responsibilities.

Sermon over for today.