Showing posts with label Consultants. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consultants. Show all posts

Monday, 3 August 2009

Competition..?

I read today in "The Lawyer" that Addleshaw Goddard was setting up a consultancy to advice other law firms on their strategic options. Interesting...

On one hand I'm very pleased that there is a recognition in Addleshaws that this needs to be done and that firms need to consider their strategy. On the other hand, however, I have a few concerns about this plan.

Addleshaw's record is perhaps less impressive that it might like as a springboard for launching this advisory service - I believe that "The Lawyer" states elsewhere on the site that AG suffered an 11% drop on revenue and 31% drop in PEP, which is rather worse than average. Usually firms would use performance which was much better that the average to launch a product such as this. What do this new group know about running a business? It is business management skills which tend to be missing from UK law firms. There is no doubt that the lawyers know their stuff - sadly their stuff rarely includes the detail behind running a multi-million pound, international company.

I also have concerns about Addleshaws offering business advice to other law firms. Before saying anything else, I should like to state what I hope is a very obvious conflict of interests. I have my own consulting firm which advises law firms, and so I'm speaking ill of a competitor. Having said that, I am independent - I do not work for a law firm. If I did, however, I'd be worries about getting advice from another law firm - even if it was hidden behind "chinese walls" from the lawyers in that firm.

I'm not sure that this is a good idea - or that it will work. If, however, it helps to raise awareness of the need for external advice for law firms, then I say "thank you" Addleshaws! Any law firm which would like completely independent advice is welcome to get in touch.

Tuesday, 28 April 2009

News, information, data and decisions

I have been looking with interest at the way that the various news agencies have been reporting the Mexican flu outbreak. Let me give you a few examples:

The deadly swine flu virus can no longer be contained, says a WHO official, as the health agency raises its alert level - from the BBC's UK News main page, Tuesday 28/04/09

The first British victims of swine flu were named today as Scottish newlyweds Iain and Dawn Askham, from Falkirk. They flew back from Cancun in Mexico last week. - Daily Mail, 28/04/09

World Health Organisation raises threat level posed by disease to unprecedented 4 as the first cases emerge in Britain - The Times, 28/09/09

First UK swine flu cases confirmed. Pandemic worries dent stock markets - Financial Times, 28/04/09

From reading these headlines - and I have deliberately only taken the headlines at the moment, it would appear that we could all well be at danger from a pandemic the size of that in 1918 which killed tens of millions.

Those were the news agencies - now let's try to dig a little deeper. Actually it's not hard. A more careful read of the items above does give a slightly different picture:

Two quotes from today's FT - Professor Neil Ferguson, a member of the WHO’s pandemic influenza taskforce, said 40 per cent of the UK population could eventually be infected if the country was hit by a pandemic.

Prof Ferguson, of London’s Imperial College, said cases were likely to die down within a matter of weeks because the UK was moving out of the normal season for flu infection, but there was a risk that the disease would flare up again once the summer was over.

He told the BBC Radio 4 Today programme the 152 deaths in Mexico probably made up a relatively small proportion of the total number infected, who might run into tens or hundreds of thousands.

“So-called bird flu - H5N1 - was a much more dangerous virus,’’ he said. “We are not in the same ballpark. But we can’t at the moment answer the question ’Is it comparable to 1918 Spanish flu, which killed a lot of people, or is it much more like Hong Kong flu?’.’’

and...

Alan Johnson, health secretary, said the UK had “established a stockpile of enough anti-viral drugs to treat more than 33m people,” or more than half the population.

I'm not sure what the opposite of alarmist is, but that would describe me. Thirty-two million people in the UK? I believe there are two reported cases at present, both of whom were in the affected area in Mexico and both of whom are responding well to treatment. That sounds a lot less alarming than describing people responding to drugs as "victims" which, perhaps only to me, implies death.

I decided to go to the source - the World Heath Organisations site. I was concerned about the threat level referred to in the "Times" and wanted to understand the scales used. I found this great graphic (see here):

Now, level 4 does look a little scary. The full text of the release from the WHO, however, stressed that the move to phase 5 was as likely as a return to phase 3 or below. The important thing I learnt from a short period of research is this: it is too early to state the extent of the outbreak.

It is a modern malaise that information is demanded so quickly. Compare the news of a flu outbreak with the on-going story of the recession. "A flu outbreak - my God. It could be pandemic. Is it pandemic - is it, is it?" we demand of scientist through our media, just as we did (and continue to do) regarding the recession "Is it worse. It's over, isn't it. House prices have gone up - we're all safe. The recession will just get worse" and so on and on. I'll repeat - it is too early to say. Both about a possible pandemic and the recession. One of the main drivers is the negative question. No credible scientist of any flavour can respond to the question "So - will you confirm that this is not a pandemic?" with anything other than a bland answer. No-one would ever say "yes" to that question because it is too early to know. Everyone knows it is too early, and yet we continue to ask. Journalists and reporters will even preface their questions with "It will be too early to say, but..."

This demand for early information and early action can be seen in business too. I spoke with a client the other day and, over a very pleasant lunch, discussed the recession and actions his firm could take. Over a particularly fine glass of wine, I explained my theory about the dangers of precipitate action and the need for good information. He generally agreed with me and then laughed and said "But you couldn't say that - either as a consultant or a CEO". I know what he meant. Organisations generally call on consultants for action and advice (or to take the blame for decisions, but that may be a different entry) and so advice consisting of "do nothing too serious yet and let's get more and better information" is unlikely to go down too well.

It is important to remember, however, that a decision based on quality information will be a quality decision. I acknowledge that one can never have perfect data and that most business decisions have to be made with a deadline in mind. Wait where possible is my message of the day.

Thursday, 23 April 2009

Research and the Competition

I was talking through a report with a client the other day. I usually offer the client a bibliography of some of the texts I used while researching the report (yes - most consultants do research. We don't just think this stuff up - it has some real legitimacy). To be honest, most clients don't want it since it seems to remind them of being in school - and some clients feel that it makes the report too academic (although it will be the same text with or without the footnotes and endnotes).

On this occasion, however, my client was enthusiastic about the bibliography and we had quite a discussion about research. I am fortunate in having a number of sources available to me. As a member of the London Business School alumni, I have access to their library, both online and on site. I have access to the Institute of Directors information sources. I have access to discussion boards all over the world. And I have access, through the delights of Google, to thousands of blogs from other consultants, economists, strategists....

It was this source that my client found most interesting. He seemed amazed that information is exchanged in this way - and relieved that most postings kept clients and client information anonymous. He asked my my list of favourites - and I'm delighted to share that with the world.
A small selection of the blogs I either find useful, interesting or amusing - and often all three. I hope you enjoy them.