Showing posts with label Revenue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Revenue. Show all posts

Thursday, 20 May 2010

Revenue down; Profit up. Is that good?

"The Lawyer" ran a story this week about the results from Denton Wilde Sapte (see here). The headline is a 22% increase in PEP while revenue has fallen.

I'm with Zook & Allen (Their excellent "Profit from the Core" - have a look on Google or buy it at Amazon - it's worth a read):
  • growing revenues but not profits does not lead to long term economic value
  • growing profits but not revenues is unsustainable
  • growing revenues and profits but not exceeding cost of capital and you just run out of capital
Let me just emphasise the second point - no firm can just increase profit but not revenues for long. It's just not sustainable.  I was so puzzled, I did some analysis, using figures from the article in "The Lawyer" above and from Dentons own web site:


Let's have a look at that in detail (and we'll ignore my mathematical dispute with the article about PEP). The number of total partners went down by 4.4% (from 181 to 173) while the number of Equity Partners increased by 1.2% (from 86 to 87). These partners produces slightly less revenue (a fall of £2.3million or 1.4%) but managed to produce significantly more profit (£5.9million or 23.3%) - leading to an increase of 29% of profit per partner (all partners) or an increase of 20% in PEP.

How is this possible? Well savage cost cutting will do some of it - although there will have been some "extraordinary costs" to go along with this sort of cost cutting (such as redundancy payments). Everyone will have been expected to work harder - or at least longer. A 29% increase in profit per partner, however, is a huge amount.

Rather than being impressed at Denton's performance, I find it rather worrying. I bet WIP has decreased - but that acts to pull revenue and profit from this year into last, which makes this year's performance more difficult. My main concern is this - what were partners doing in the years before that they could pull an increase in profit per partner of 29% out of the bag. Were they all going home early?  Were they just not billing for some hours? Will this new level of profitability be maintained? Was this increased profit paid to partners at the expense of retaining money for investing in the firm and its future?

My other concern would be as a client. Look at it from their point of view - Dentons have screwed more money out of every penny spent by clients. If I was one of those clients, I'd want a share of that increase profit.

Increasing profits without increasing revenue is unsustainable. It simply is. This might be a "blip" year for Dentons - but I'd still be worried and would be concentrating hard on ensuring that there was sufficient investment in the future and that there was a good, sustainable, long term plan.

I'd probably stop making such a noise about profitability and PEP in a difficult market too!


Tuesday, 10 November 2009

Growth in a Downturn - Revenue or Cost Driven?


It's results time again, when the legal press focus in minute detail on short-term results - thereby increasing lawyers' focus on results in the last 3 months, 6 months or 12 months, all of which are too short term.

The news this time round is continuing revenue falls in some of the big players, headed up by Simmons who posted a 16% fall in revenues (see the full story here). A&O also show a fall - Norton Rose and Lovells are expecting flat results. All of these firms have been cost cutting, and it will be interesting to read the results of the mid tier firms where cost cutting has been the most savage. The evidence would seem to suggest that cost cutting hasn't helped enough - or perhaps they will suggest that it was going to be much worse. By focussing on cost cutting, some firms will have dropped the ball with regard to business development, which, I suggest, is the real way out of the downturn.

It's not been all bad news. Dentons posted a 3.5% rise in revenue in the same period (see here) - for which they thanked not savage cost cutting, but rises in international revenues.

The message has always been - the best way out of a downturn is a focus on revenues not on const-cutting. This article gives an interesting take, and sums up by saying "...do not sacrifice the future [by one-shot cost reducing savagery]" and encouraging firms to concentrate on cash efficiency and revenue growth. In another part of the same article, the author tells firms not to retreat - no matter the temptation, do not hide from the storm, but instead aim to work hard to grow your revenues. The author quotes a Harvard Business Review article which states:
Of the firms that made major gains in revenue or profitability during the last recession, more than 70% sustained those gains through the next boom cycle. The corollary was also true: fewer than 30% of those that lost ground were able to regain their positions.

Growth in a downturn is driven by revenue, not by cost cutting. I am not suggesting that any firm should ignore costs. Have a sensible policy to manage costs sensibly - but have the lawyers doing what they do best which is to provide high quality business advice, manage their clients, find new clients and find new work. Costs are important, and client & matter partners must have a very good understanding of their costs in order to be sure that their work is profitable - but their responsibility is to drive forward the revenue side of profit, while letting the managers of the business manage the cost side of profit.

Manage the costs, but work for the revenue - it's the only way forward.

Thursday, 30 July 2009

Turnover and PEP in UK Law Firms - More Thoughts

I blogged earlier this months about statistics and the need for a longer term view (see here). Today "Legal Week" has written about firms' turnover and PEP figures - and the need for longer term measures.

A small amount of analysis shows some interesting information. The top 50 UK firms' data from 2001 to 2009 is very interesting. Using the "Legal Week" data, I looked to see what would have happened to a firm which in 2001 had a turnover of £70 million and PEP of £250,000. By 2009, the data suggests it would have had a turnover of just under £135 million and PEP of just under £350,000 - rises of 92.8% and 38.7% respectively. Not too shabby at all.

As expected, the firms at the top of the list for year-on-year growth tend not to be those showing the highest for turnover and PEP in 2009. In fact only one firm in the top 10 for PEP made it in the top 10 for turnover growth (DLA Piper with Average PEP of £645k and turnover growth from 2008 of 16.3%). There was also only one firm in the top 10 of revenue per lawyer (RPL) in 2009 which made the top 10 for profit growth from the previous year (Freshfields with RPL of £400.4k and profit growth of 0.6%).

More interestingly 6 firms made both the top 10 for turnover growth and the top 10 for profit growth (Kennedys, Berrymans, HFW, Ince, WFW and Clyde).

All this just adds weight to the need for longer term measures rather than focussing on year-on-year PEP. I propose a move to publishing different measures as a matter of course:
  • Five year average PEP
  • Five year PEP growth
  • Five year average Revenue per Lawyer
  • Five year RPL growth
  • Five year average profit
  • Five year profit growth
Each of these should be easily available - and the five years' data should be published in graphic form to make it even easier to see the trends.

Friday, 17 July 2009

Statistics, Damned Lies, and Context


The legal press is enjoying itself at the moment in reporting falls in PEP figures. Both "The Lawyer" and "Legal Week" have published lists recently.

Not quite at random, I decided to have a look at a few firms either side of the £100m mark (using 2009 revenue as data). Before I continue with the analysis, I should like to repeat a mantra I learnt at London Business School: "Turnover is vanity, profit is sanity and cashflow is reality". I frequently mention my concerns at the measurements used in law firms - particularly a delight in reporting revenue figures (which really don't mean much and can fool lawyers into taking work with lots of turnover and no profit). Having said that, the numbers seem striking at first pass.

Firstly let's look at revenue in 2008 and 2009 (as reported in "The Lawyer):
Firm Name 2009 Rev(£M) 2008 Rev(£M) % change
Linklaters 1,300 1,293 0.54%
Freshfields 1,290 1,180 9.32%
Clifford Chance 1,260 1,330 (5.26%)
Lovells 531 479 10.86%
Eversheds 366 390 (6.15%)
Norton Rose Group 314 297 5.72%
Ashurst 301 323 (6.81%)
CMS Cameron McKenna 240 236 1.91%
Taylor Wessing 188 185 1.67%
Clyde & Co LLP 185 157 17.83%
Addleshaw Goddard 173 195 (11.41%)
Denton Wilde Sapte LLP 170 164 3.28%
Nabarro 127 142 (11.17%)
Beachcroft LLP 121 114 6.14%
Trowers 90 78 15.34%
Stephenson Harwood 85 85 (0.23%)
Hill Dickinson 82 73 12.18%
WFW 74 59 24.58%
Charles Russell LLP 70 71 (1.70%)
Kennedys 67 52 30.68%
DWF 60 55 8.68%
Dickinson Dees LLP 54 60 (10.33%)
Mishcon de Reya 47 47 0.42%
Shepherd & Wedderburn 40 43 (7.04%)
TLT LLP 39 41 (4.88%)
Manches 34 34 (0.87%)
Morgan Cole 34 32 4.36%
Bircham Dyson Bell 32 36 (8.73%)
Across this group, the average increase in revenue is 2.82%. The average of the top 50 firms in 2007/2008 was 12.5% according to "Legal Week".

Now PEP for the same group in the same period:
Firm Name 2009 PEP 2008 PEP PEP % change
Linklaters 1,302 1,440 (9.58%)
Freshfields 1,440 1,440 0.00%
Clifford Chance 733 1,150 (36.26%)
Lovells 585 661 (11.50%)
Eversheds 404 552 (26.81%)
Norton Rose Group 517 625 (17.28%)
Ashurst 673 1,040 (35.29%)
CMS Cameron McKenna 554 650 (14.77%)
Taylor Wessing 369 457 (19.26%)
Clyde & Co LLP 550 550 0.00%
Addleshaw Goddard 405 586 (30.89%)
Denton Wilde Sapte LLP 300 470 (36.17%)
Nabarro 375 610 (38.52%)
Beachcroft LLP 301 310 (2.90%)
Trowers 509 515 (1.17%)
Stephenson Harwood 610 620 (1.61%)
Hill Dickinson 294 312 (5.77%)
WFW 430 424 1.42%
Charles Russell LLP 235 390 (39.74%)
Kennedys 350 300 16.67%
DWF 260 350 (25.71%)
Dickinson Dees LLP 150 336 (55.36%)
Mishcon de Reya 575 740 (22.30%)
Shepherd & Wedderburn 230 311 (26.05%)
TLT LLP 198 268 (26.12%)
Manches 209 227 (7.93%)
Morgan Cole 218 241 (9.54%)
Bircham Dyson Bell 230 312 (26.28%)
Across this group, the average decrease in PEP was 18.1% compared with an average increase for Legal Week's top 50 for 2007/2008 of 7.3%.


On the left you can see a chart of the changes in revenue and PEP for the "Over £100m" group mentioned above. It is rather depressing, I agree, but really what is required is a longer term understanding of both of these figures. I would like to see these measurements for as many firms as possible over a five or ten year period. This is much more likely to give useful information and to provide an insight into the health of individual firms. It can also provide a useful context for analysts to be able to comment on a single year. Is a reduction in PEP of 11% bad? I don't know. In the context of five years of over 10% growth - no, probably not. In the context of five years of reductions in PEP - probably yes.

The reduction in PEP was surely coming. A combination of tax payments for the previous year, reduced client spending, additional extraordinary expenditure to get rid of (possibly too many) staff and a lag in reductions in other expenditures made a reduction in PEP very predictable. What is interesting is in how the changes seem to affect firms with all sizes of turnover.

My point is that firms should not use a reduction in PEP in one year as a signal for further panic measures. Now is the time to speak with the partners and to explain that PEP will be cyclical; that PEP is in any case a fairly poor measurement of the firm's well being - it is far too short-term a measure; and that now is the time to look for efficiencies rather than savings. Now is the time to ensure that every process in the firm is working effectively not just cheaply. Now is also the time to work very hard at the firm's marketing and business development. The partners should be concentrating on excellence in client work, client retention and finding new clients - and not much more. Now is the time that they must (a) make sure they have world-class business support staff; that (b) they have a clear and concise strategy; and that (c) they let the experts concentrate on their areas of expertise - let the partners run the legal side of the business and let the firms executives run the business.

Does PEP matter? Yes - sadly it does. Firms seem to need to have one measure of comparison and have jumped at using PEP. I suggest a move to looking at trend data - PEP over a rolling 5 and 10 year period and revenue on the same basis. How about profit figures for individual cases and business units - I realise that these will never be published, but surely these are a more useful measurement for any firm's management.

Well done to those firm's who either managed to increase PEP or kept the reduction to a minimum - but let's not pretend that data for one year means that much. Legal week have an interesting article looking at five year trends - this is surely the way forward.







I should like to add, as a postscript, that now is probably a very good time for law firms to hiring high quality consulting advice in the areas of structural planning, efficiency, process planning, training and risk. Happily I know one or two firms who can help with that....