Showing posts with label Communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Communication. Show all posts

Monday, 8 July 2013

Communication, Transparency & Democracy - and Leadership

Many sets of chambers and law firms suffer from a surfeit of democracy in a mis-guided belief that  this is the best and fairest way to make decisions. It rarely is.

There is a confusion in many of these sorts of organisations that communication means meetings, and that every member of the organisation should be involved in decisions. In discussions, most people will agree that they don't need to be involved in every decision - just the important ones…

This generally leads to a sclerosis - a situation where change becomes impossible and each new level of decision has to be preceded by open and full discussion leading to changes in the terms of reference for the decision leading to new demands for discussion since the context of the last discussion has changed…

It can be enormously frustrating for those caught up in it - even those causing the sclerosis can feel hugely frustrated.

The way out of this is through much less democracy - but balanced off with much more openness, more transparency and much more communication. So - let's say that a decision has to be made about leasing a building. A small group is appointed to examine the options and propose a single decision. The appointment of the group is made public within the organisation as is their job. The proposal they make is available not only to the Management Committee or Board but to the members of the organisation too.

Their proposal is examined by the appointed Management Committee or Board (having made it clear that a decision was going to be made) who make a decision. This decision is communicated to the organisation as soon as possible.

This process allows those who have strong opinions to make them and those who would like to get involved to get involved. It allows the body appointed to make decisions to make those decisions.

What I am talking about, of course, is Leadership - something sadly lacking in too many organisations. Leadership does involve good management, but it is more than that. It is taking a position, it is driving a message, it is communicating and, while listening, pushing the message to everyone in the organisation. It is about passion and belief in the way that the organisation needs to move. It is about taking a risk when necessary, being honest when 'fudging' the message would be easier, and about doing the difficult things yourself.

I didn't say it was easy...

Monday, 3 June 2013

Getting the message right - the V word...

I am always surprised at the poor press that barristers get. The public's perception of a barrister in my fantastically unscientific survey (i.e. I asked those friends who weren't lawyers) is that lawyers are posh, articulate, and usually very highly paid.

I'm not sure where that last perception has come from. Yes it is true that some barristers - usually commercial lawyers - are very well rewarded for the work they do. Most, however, work to generate a comfortable (and no more) existence. My surprise, however, is that the barristers' union (for want or another work), the Bar Council, seems to have been unable or unwilling to change the perception.

I was struck again by this since I am again acting as Interim Chambers Director - this time for East Anglian Chambers, based in Ipswich (but throughout the region). I am working there three days a week and had briefly forgotten that barristers seem to do the business of chambers after 8pm or before 7 am.

Let's do a quick calculation. Assume that our barrister earns £100,000 a year. That sounds a lot doesn't it? But our barrister is self-employed (as they mostly are - certainly almost all the good ones) and so that is a turnover figure. We need to take off VAT - leaving £80,000. Next come overheads - chambers will take a percentage. Let's say that's 17.5% (that's about average). Suddenly our barrister has only £66,000 left from which to pay other costs (including travel) and tax. It doesn't seem like quite such a huge number any more, does it?

Assuming that travel is about £1,000 per month I will take a figure for other costs of £20,000 - which is probably very light. So - now there is £46,000 left. Let's say that they put in ten hours a day - which is about right  - and then another ten hours over the weekend (probably a vast under estimate). That's a 60 hour week. Being self-employed, most barristers will be looking at about a 280 to 300 day year. Being generous and taking the lower figure, this comes down to a daily rate of £164.29 or £16.43 an hour.

I'm not trying to act as an apologist for barristers. They are well paid in comparison to many people, but it still isn't the sort of money that the Ministry of Justice has been slinging around.

Many criminal barristers will be earning much less that £100,000 too.

My point is this. Barristers generally work long and hard for what turns out to be a good but far from generous salary. Their representative body should be shouting about this from the roof tops. Yes, of course some barristers earn millions - but so do some doctors and we rarely begrudge them.

It is important that the message - the right message - is got across. Barristers are good value - that is the word we should all be using.

Sunday, 17 February 2013

There's Horse Meat in my Legal Services

The press are having a wonderful time at the moment with the 'horse meat scandal'. It must be a scandal, since the BBC has said so...

It is undoubtedly a problem. The issue does, however, seem to be one of the labelling rather than of the provision of dangerous food. I'm not trying to trivialise the matter - but I do think it's important to remember that, so far as I am aware, there are no reported cases of poisoning, and no-one has been hospitalised.

The story has moved on over the last few days to the point where there are discussions and assertions that the issue is one of the 'every growing demand for cheaper food' and so suppliers may have been driven to find alternative sources for food and, again may, have been less that diligent in checking how a supplier could provide beef at a very low price.

The drive for goods or services at low prices driving down standards... That has a ring of familiarity. The Government is determined to reduce the cost of justice and, at the moment, it would appear that this drive for low price is being done at the expense of quality or standards. Again, it may be a matter of  labelling...

Most people, happily, have little understanding or direct knowledge of the criminal justice system - and long may that continue. I have asked a few friends who have no direct connection of the law how they thought the system would work. These were bright, well read individuals. I asked what they thought would happen if they were arrested for a crime. Most thought that they would be provided with a qualified solicitor at the police station if they did not have access to their own solicitor. If the case went to court most assumed that their solicitor - the same solicitor who saw them at the police station - would be supported by a barrister.

I asked about the meaning of 'solicitor' and would they be happy that they were supported at the police station by a trained legal representative; I asked if they would be content to have a 'solicitor advocate' appear for them in court. Most had no idea of the difference or if the difference was important.

I do not suggest that there is a problem if you are represented by a solicitor advocate rather than a barrister (although I would possibly prefer a barrister for something complicated, that is personal preference rather than anything else). I do, however, suggest that we are not labelling the service properly so that clients can make their own mind up. There should be much more transparency about the various roles within the legal system and of what your choices are or will be. You should be clearly told who and what the person representing you is - whether for the prosecution or for the defence.

If I buy beef, I expect to eat beef. If I am represented in court, I expect a barrister - at the very least I must be made aware of the fact that my advocate is not a barrister, and of what that means. That way there is a chance for me to make an informed choice.

By fudging the issue and by being less transparent than the industry could and should be, we may be paving the way for yet another 'scandal' in the future.

Wednesday, 17 October 2012

Starting on the wrong foot...

Over the weekend, some kind person hit my car while it was parked, causing quite a lot of damage. I mention this for two reasons. Firstly there is always a (I admit very slight) chance that the fine person who hit me (I was parked on a Sunday on a quiet street in EC4, City of London) simply forgot to leave their name and contact details and so will take this opportunity to get in touch.

Secondly, it means that I have been in contact with my insurer. To be honest, it wasn't something that I was looking forward to because in the past (and with other insurance companies, I should add) communication has been difficult.

I'm insured with Sheila's Wheels (mostly for my wife's amusement - she likes the idea of me having to tell people that). I called the claims line and got a recorded message asking me to confirm that I could answer "yes" to four questions - all to do with making fraudulent claims. Having done that I spoke with a very pleasant chap who dealt with everything efficiently, politely and quickly. 

It was, however, an unfortunate start to a relationship or a communication. Like most insured people, I have no intention of making a fraudulent claim and feel a little aggrieved that this is the first thing that is mentioned. I understand that it is perhaps something that they need to get out of the way - but there must be a better way of starting a phone call - particularly when it is a claims line which means that anyone calling is likely to be a little upset already.

The same happens (or should happen...) in barristers' chambers. the Bar Standards Board require sets to write to the lay client - in every case, and at the beginning of the case - to explain the complaints procedure should they wish to make a claim. Again - I understand that the BSB are trying to make it easy for ordinary people to be able to complain about a professional. It is, however, a very unfortunate star: "Hello, sir. I'm your barrister, Mr. Blair. If you want to complain about me, this is how to do it".

In this day and age of technology, there must be a better way. Surely every case could be centrally logged (automatically from the firm or chambers case management system) with a single reference number (on a card with a QR or bar code perhaps), from which the client can access information about every person (solicitor, barrister, case worker, etc) who has dealt with their case. Quick, simple, and it avoids starting off on the wrong foot.

Friday, 17 August 2012

Beginnings

Beginnings are great times.

I had a meeting yesterday in which I introduced an old friend to a new acquaintance and managed to bring in some other new great contacts.

The subject was email encryption. I do a little bit of consulting about technology - but mostly in the area of user interface or in helping a firm to build a specification for the system they want. This does mean that I meet a few IT people and see some good software. Email encryption is the last great 'necessary' that has to be addressed. Almost no-one uses it because it is a real pain. Law firms have a regulatory duty to secure information they send - but they can get away with 'best endeavours' because dual key encryption is so confusing. The system offered by mKryptor uses no add-ins and no shared keys - and yet manages to offer instant, secure, communications to and from anyone. Superb.

A new colleague/acquaintance/friend had mentioned email encryption and I in turn mentioned the good people at mKryptor (see here). I set up a meeting for Simon and Beatrice to meet my new friend and was happy that the wonderful Paul Rodger from Bull Rodger (more details here) had come along. I've known Paul for a few years and he is a wonderful design/brand/marketing/communications guru (and I hasten to add that I haven't yet got round to getting him to re-design my own branding. Isn't that the way with old friends! So all the design mess you see here and on my website is my fault, not his). He is one of those people who can listen to you describe something and then offer a totally unique insight - and then find a way of describing your own USP in a brand and design. It's a special skill.

It was wonderful to see someone else 'get' mKryptor. That moment in which they suddenly understand the difference and what all the fuss is about. The moment in which they realise that this is all really rather special.

I hasten to add that I have no formal connection to either company - I just happen to think that email encryption is necessary and that mKryptor is, by far, the best way of doing it. I also think that Bull Rodger (who did all of mKryptor's design and branding - so have a look and be impressed) are the best at what they do.

This is the way of business amongst independent organisations - a loose network of expertise. Have a look  - I'm sure you will be impressed too.



Monday, 25 January 2010

If you're going to do it, do it properly

I have spent some time over the last few days looking at a number of websites for both legal providers and for small charities. It has been an interesting exercise, and some interesting things became very obvious to me.

The first of these is that many law firms - and regional law firms do seem to be rather worse in this respect - seem to have spent a very small amount of money on their website, and to have spent this some time ago. Since that small expenditure they have obviously not felt it necessary to either spend any more keeping it up to date, or even to have visited it recently. The shining star in this regard was the site of Connell Associates (http://www.connellassociates.co.uk/). Until very recently, they had a spectacularly bad web site, full of typographical errors, spelling errors, and sentences that made no sense at all. They have now, as you will have seen if you clicked on the link above, put a new "holding" page in place which is, at least, in English this time. Congratulations on doing something about the mess that was your last site.

Sadly they are not unusual. Many of the sites I have been visiting appear to have been written by someone's 14 year old nephew who has spent many minutes learning to write HTML or to use Dreamweaver. Few have given any thought to their design and many are so badly put together that they are difficult to read. This from a profession which professes to be concerned about the details.

What is more interesting, however, is the amount of space spent on profiles of the partners and lawyers and copies of things they might have written. The sites appear to be based on the principle of "they [the clients] will want to know about us". As a client, I'm not sure I care about the lawyers - I'm more interested in what they will do for me. A remarkably small number of law firm websites had any form of recommendation or review from clients.

Contrast that with many of the small charity sites I have been looking at. An almost equal number of them appear to have been designed by amateurs, but what is really interesting is their focus. It can be hard to find profiles of the people running the charity. Instead the sites focus on the activities of the charity and often have quotes from the beneficiaries - the "clients".

This is all by way of continuing my theme of placing the client at the heart of what your organisation does. The law firms were remiss in that they seems to avoid even mentioning their clients - which certainly gives the impression that they don't really care that much and will expect a client to fit in with what they do.

This is not complicated. It's quite a simple exercise to sit down and think about what the clients want. You could even ask them... Personal clients of law firms who are looking at a web site for the first time will have two main concerns - neither of which are usually addressed. The first is - can this firm do the work properly. This can be addressed by client quotations, recommendations and, perhaps, by a survey ("80% of our clients were delighted with this service in our recent poll", for example). The issue of cost can be addressed by showing fixed prices on the web site. Most sites I viewed went very far out of their way to avoid this. As a prospective client who is shopping around, I do not want to visit a web site to be told that I need to phone someone to get a price.  Nor does saying that the first meeting, or first half hour, is free - I still want to know how much it will be after that.

So - both types of organisations can improve. Expenditure on a web site is an investment. Have a professional design and professional implementation - it does not need to be vastly expensive. Secondly - address the concerns of your clients. If you don't know what these are, then ask!

I will now declare an interest - I recommend the following site as a good example of an effective web site. It is the site for The Living Rainforest - and my interest is that I am the Chairman. Notwithstanding this - the site addresses the key audience and gives out the required information. It is simple, easy to use, gives good information - and, vitally so far as I was concerned - was excellent value for money. Have a look and see if you agree with me.

Tuesday, 28 April 2009

News, information, data and decisions

I have been looking with interest at the way that the various news agencies have been reporting the Mexican flu outbreak. Let me give you a few examples:

The deadly swine flu virus can no longer be contained, says a WHO official, as the health agency raises its alert level - from the BBC's UK News main page, Tuesday 28/04/09

The first British victims of swine flu were named today as Scottish newlyweds Iain and Dawn Askham, from Falkirk. They flew back from Cancun in Mexico last week. - Daily Mail, 28/04/09

World Health Organisation raises threat level posed by disease to unprecedented 4 as the first cases emerge in Britain - The Times, 28/09/09

First UK swine flu cases confirmed. Pandemic worries dent stock markets - Financial Times, 28/04/09

From reading these headlines - and I have deliberately only taken the headlines at the moment, it would appear that we could all well be at danger from a pandemic the size of that in 1918 which killed tens of millions.

Those were the news agencies - now let's try to dig a little deeper. Actually it's not hard. A more careful read of the items above does give a slightly different picture:

Two quotes from today's FT - Professor Neil Ferguson, a member of the WHO’s pandemic influenza taskforce, said 40 per cent of the UK population could eventually be infected if the country was hit by a pandemic.

Prof Ferguson, of London’s Imperial College, said cases were likely to die down within a matter of weeks because the UK was moving out of the normal season for flu infection, but there was a risk that the disease would flare up again once the summer was over.

He told the BBC Radio 4 Today programme the 152 deaths in Mexico probably made up a relatively small proportion of the total number infected, who might run into tens or hundreds of thousands.

“So-called bird flu - H5N1 - was a much more dangerous virus,’’ he said. “We are not in the same ballpark. But we can’t at the moment answer the question ’Is it comparable to 1918 Spanish flu, which killed a lot of people, or is it much more like Hong Kong flu?’.’’

and...

Alan Johnson, health secretary, said the UK had “established a stockpile of enough anti-viral drugs to treat more than 33m people,” or more than half the population.

I'm not sure what the opposite of alarmist is, but that would describe me. Thirty-two million people in the UK? I believe there are two reported cases at present, both of whom were in the affected area in Mexico and both of whom are responding well to treatment. That sounds a lot less alarming than describing people responding to drugs as "victims" which, perhaps only to me, implies death.

I decided to go to the source - the World Heath Organisations site. I was concerned about the threat level referred to in the "Times" and wanted to understand the scales used. I found this great graphic (see here):

Now, level 4 does look a little scary. The full text of the release from the WHO, however, stressed that the move to phase 5 was as likely as a return to phase 3 or below. The important thing I learnt from a short period of research is this: it is too early to state the extent of the outbreak.

It is a modern malaise that information is demanded so quickly. Compare the news of a flu outbreak with the on-going story of the recession. "A flu outbreak - my God. It could be pandemic. Is it pandemic - is it, is it?" we demand of scientist through our media, just as we did (and continue to do) regarding the recession "Is it worse. It's over, isn't it. House prices have gone up - we're all safe. The recession will just get worse" and so on and on. I'll repeat - it is too early to say. Both about a possible pandemic and the recession. One of the main drivers is the negative question. No credible scientist of any flavour can respond to the question "So - will you confirm that this is not a pandemic?" with anything other than a bland answer. No-one would ever say "yes" to that question because it is too early to know. Everyone knows it is too early, and yet we continue to ask. Journalists and reporters will even preface their questions with "It will be too early to say, but..."

This demand for early information and early action can be seen in business too. I spoke with a client the other day and, over a very pleasant lunch, discussed the recession and actions his firm could take. Over a particularly fine glass of wine, I explained my theory about the dangers of precipitate action and the need for good information. He generally agreed with me and then laughed and said "But you couldn't say that - either as a consultant or a CEO". I know what he meant. Organisations generally call on consultants for action and advice (or to take the blame for decisions, but that may be a different entry) and so advice consisting of "do nothing too serious yet and let's get more and better information" is unlikely to go down too well.

It is important to remember, however, that a decision based on quality information will be a quality decision. I acknowledge that one can never have perfect data and that most business decisions have to be made with a deadline in mind. Wait where possible is my message of the day.

Saturday, 21 February 2009

Communicating

I've been looking at definitions of communication (I've had that sort of weekend). For once I almost agreed with a Wikipedia entry. In its entry for communications, it includes "Communication requires that all parties have an area of communicative commonality". It's that "...communicative commonality." that I think is interesting.

It take  to mean that everyone involved needs to understand and agree what they are trying to do. In my experience of dealing with people in organisations, this is usually a problem. It is also usually a step that is either ignored or simply not done.

When was the last time that you sat with colleagues and said "what are we trying to do - are we all sure?". Perhaps you work in an enlightened organisation, but it's rare, I think. Equally - how often have you left a meeting and thought "what was that about?" or "what was agreed?" or even "did we agree anything?".

I'd love to say that I always sorted communications for everything that I do. I do, however, try to focus on the problem as often as possible and have noticed that - surprise, surprise - projects where I take the time to sort out the communications in advance (and as we go along) tend to work that bit better. I remember a story about Jack Nicklaus (a stunning golfer, for those of you depressingly younger than me) who was complemented on his luck on a golf course. "Yup" he said, "and the more I practise, the luckier I get."

My point (yes, I did have one) is that we should all try to ensure open communications. 

More on this subject in future posts.