Showing posts with label News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label News. Show all posts

Monday, 8 July 2013

Communication, Transparency & Democracy - and Leadership

Many sets of chambers and law firms suffer from a surfeit of democracy in a mis-guided belief that  this is the best and fairest way to make decisions. It rarely is.

There is a confusion in many of these sorts of organisations that communication means meetings, and that every member of the organisation should be involved in decisions. In discussions, most people will agree that they don't need to be involved in every decision - just the important ones…

This generally leads to a sclerosis - a situation where change becomes impossible and each new level of decision has to be preceded by open and full discussion leading to changes in the terms of reference for the decision leading to new demands for discussion since the context of the last discussion has changed…

It can be enormously frustrating for those caught up in it - even those causing the sclerosis can feel hugely frustrated.

The way out of this is through much less democracy - but balanced off with much more openness, more transparency and much more communication. So - let's say that a decision has to be made about leasing a building. A small group is appointed to examine the options and propose a single decision. The appointment of the group is made public within the organisation as is their job. The proposal they make is available not only to the Management Committee or Board but to the members of the organisation too.

Their proposal is examined by the appointed Management Committee or Board (having made it clear that a decision was going to be made) who make a decision. This decision is communicated to the organisation as soon as possible.

This process allows those who have strong opinions to make them and those who would like to get involved to get involved. It allows the body appointed to make decisions to make those decisions.

What I am talking about, of course, is Leadership - something sadly lacking in too many organisations. Leadership does involve good management, but it is more than that. It is taking a position, it is driving a message, it is communicating and, while listening, pushing the message to everyone in the organisation. It is about passion and belief in the way that the organisation needs to move. It is about taking a risk when necessary, being honest when 'fudging' the message would be easier, and about doing the difficult things yourself.

I didn't say it was easy...

Thursday, 25 October 2012

Noticing the Mood of the Market

There are times when lawyers really don't help themselves.

Anyone who knows me will know that I do not profess to be a marketing person. I like to think, however, that I understand how to judge the mood of my market place. Sadly it would seem that, at least, the legal press either don't understand the mood of the 'ordinary person' (i.e. not a lawyer), or that they have judged the mood of their market (i.e. lawyers) perfectly and it is the lawyers themselves who are out of step. Let's hope it is the later.

I am talking about a headline in "The Lawyer" today (see their full story here):

Perhaps I'm being over-sensitive. To me, however, when I read this I have a mental picture of a money-grabbing lawyer delighting in suffering in order to win large fees from (ideally unnecessary) lawsuits. let me stress that I am sure this is absolutely not the case at Reed Smith or Bakers - however it would be easy to get that impression from the rather delighted tone of the headline.

Perception is an important thing, and these sort of headlines really don't help. 

Friday, 24 June 2011

What Do Lawyers Care About - Weekly Result

So - a whole week of analysing the news page of "The Lawyer" (on the principle that this will reflect the things that lawyers care about) and what can we say. Well - let's first look at the charts.

The split of topics discussed (and I immediately admit that my categories are completely arbitrary) is as follows (click on the picture for an enlarged version:

I then further grouped my categories into "About Lawyers" and "About Clients":

So - after a week of looking at the news topics aimed at lawyers, it would appear that most of the discussion (90% in fact) concerns lawyers themselves rather than anything at all about their clients. Given that "The Lawyer" is a public forum, I'm a little surprised to see that lawyers are apparently so little concerned about their clients. Surely the best advertisement about the quality of a firm or a lawyer is success on behalf of their clients - and yet stories about "Client Success" occupied only 3.3% of the news. Maybe it was a quiet week...

Less surprising to me was the fact that a third of the stories were to do with lawyers moving firms and that a further 16.7% were about the money that lawyers earn. Together these made up a very neat 50% of the news - and therefore, arguably, what lawyers care about.

So what?

Well - even if lawyers really do care so little about their clients, I'd suggest that their PR people work harder on positive stories about the work done for clients. We do look at these sort of news pages, you know. And if lawyers really do care about their clients - and lets say that most of them do - then they should be talking about that more, and about how much they and their firms earn a great deal less.

Monday, 20 June 2011

What Do Lawyers Care About?

As someone who works with lawyers, it is important that I should understand the people I need to communicate with - and so I need to understand what lawyers themselves care about. One way of finding this out, I assume, is to read the news that lawyers read. My thinking is that news outlets which service lawyers ("The Lawyer" for example) will be sure that they are addressing their core audience and so providing news that lawyers care about.

On this assumption, I decided to analyse the main news section of "The Lawyer" for a week. I used the on-line version and took the headlines as they were at about 9am. I should like to point out that this is far from a scientific survey - I will only be doing an analysis for five days, I will be checking at some point between 9am and 10am, and will be assigning news to categories myself, as I see fit. Nevertheless, I hope it will prove instructive.

To get things going, my analysis of the news at 9am today is as follows:

So, with the caveats above and noting that this is one morning and so may not be representative, it would appear that lawyers care most about news about themselves rather than news about their clients.

This may not be a surprise since this is a journal aimed at lawyers not their clients. I should, however, be concerned if this pattern remains. It is all very well to be interested in who is working where and how much they earn - but this is a public forum and, as a potential client, I should like to see that client success was at the forefront of concern for any lawyer. Most firms will say something similar on their publications - but the news from "The Lawyer" would suggest something else.

Watch this space for some (slightly) more reliable data.