Showing posts with label Style. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Style. Show all posts

Thursday, 15 April 2010

Style and Substance

So - the great UK "Leaders' Debate" starts this evening. The leaders of the three main political parties will engage in a live TV debate (the first of three) in what is supposed to be the centre-piece of the forthcoming general election. Most of the media agencies have been gearing up for these debates for ages (take the BBC for example) - desperately trying to encourage the viewing/listening/reading public to believe that these debates are fantastically important to the outcome of the election. Sadly they are probably right.

I say sadly because I would really like the election to be decided by issues of policy and belief. I agree with Alex Thomson of Channel 4 News who said (sarcastically) today on his Twitter feed:
"Thankfully election TV debates are decided by serious issues like sweat, suits, looking at watches, put-downs and one-liners... Not trivia like policy, candour or answering a question"
In another part of their site (here), the BBC itemise the ways in which the debates could change the election and cite "The Gaffe" and "The Reaction Shot" amongst their list. I find this very depressing - that there is so little to choose - apparently - amongst the main parties that an accidental error in an 90 minute live broadcast or even a look of surprise or anger might swing the election. Are we electing the best party to run the country - and don't forget that we actually don't get to vote on the party leader unless we happen to be a member of that party (there is nothing to stop all three parties changing leader the day after the election) - or are we electing the best performer, the best trained actor or the main with the best media coach?

In an ideal world it should be both style and substance. In an ideal election we would all:
  1. Know the policies of all the parties in detail
  2. Be in a position to question both our own local candidate and party leaders
  3. Have a good understanding of our own context and that of the country and understand the macro political/economic/social environment - and so be able to select the most appropriate leaders
All that being equal we might easily then choose the best looking candidate or the one with the best sense of humour or dress. I suggest however that the substance is more important than the style.

Of course, we are not engaged in an ideal election. The parties seem to assume that we all care about style and that the detail of the content - the real substance of their case - can wait until after the election. Vague promises seem to be the order of the day. It is, after all, about politics - not about common sense.

I had a discussion yesterday with a friend in a law firm who will soon be voting for a new Managing Partner. It would seem that he is in the same position as I am with the "Leaders' Debate". The candidates for Managing Partner (I was going to shorten that to MP but even I found it confusing) are already positioning themselves with regard to the wider partnership and political stances are being taken. Promises are being made and factions established. I suggested, naively it turns out, that the partners should ask the candidates about their leadership styles and about their managerial experience and plans. "Don't be ridiculous", I was told "it's not about skills - its about power". It is, apparently, about who has built the best power-base; who has the right "friends" and about who has made the right promises.

In law firms, as with the country as a whole, it would seem that (often) style is much more important than substance. Sadly even if I accept that this statement is true (and I suppose that I have to) - it is only true during an election. After the election it is the substance that will be important - the substance that will drag the economy out of the mess it is in and the substance that will position the country (or the firm) over the next four to five years. Surely, then, we should all be looking for our leaders a little more closely through the style at the substance?

Tuesday, 5 May 2009

Management Style - How Robust Can You Be?

I have been thinking a lot recently about styles in management. I have been lucky enough to have worked for some wonderful managers & leaders in my time, and have worked for my fair share of people who had no concept of leadership and couldn't manage their way out of a paper bag. So what is it that makes the difference - and can it be learnt?

This train of thought was really started by a discussion with a client about his own management style which he considered a little "autocratic". One question he had was "Where does being able to make difficult decisions stop, and bullying start?". I think that any manager/leader who even asks this question - and thereby accepts the possibility th
at there may be things to learn - is likely to be falling on the right side of that particular divide. Nevertheless, it started me thinking.

Stefan Stern wrote his blog yesterday about the "Bully-boy school of management". He makes a good point about bullying managers being isolated from facts because staff become
too scared to bring him (and it is usually a him) bad news. He also spoke, in his blog, about the need for some managers to win at all costs. Winning is a difficult word for managers - everyone likes to not only be a winner but to be recognised as a winner. Google "Winning" and "Management" together will produce over 60 million entries. MSNBC quote a Business Week article ("Are you a good leader. Follow these rules - Management 101") which includes the rule "Winning at all costs is for losers".

So - no winning at all costs, then, and no bullying. So where does robust come in then. Well the MSNBC article has, at rule 4 "Tell the truth" and at rule 8 "Take responsibility for your mistakes".

I would add my own absolute rule - "Make decisions, even if they are unpopular and difficult". I suspect we have all worked for at least one prevaricator and have learnt how difficult it is if the person in charge will just not decide things. 

So - just how robust can you be? That depends (you can tell that I'm a consultant...). The more difficult the situation the organisation finds itself in, the more robust a leader must be. Swift and decisive is the style most required in a crisis. In better times, however, there is more time to consult - and that is what a good leader should do.

I think I can summarise as follows - be robust, but do it well.