Showing posts with label Professionalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Professionalism. Show all posts

Friday, 9 August 2013

Get a Professional

The days of the enthusiastic amateur - so far as running a legal business is concerned - are over.

In the past a law firm - even a large law firm - was entirely run by a management board headed up by a Senior Partner and/or a Managing Partner. In some cases the Managing Partner might have a discount from his or her billing target in recognition of the work they did to run the firm - but I've seen law firms with a turnover of nearly £50million where no-one got a discount. This means that the management of the firm - the discussion and setting of strategy, the planning to implement the strategy, the measurement of performance, fee-earner motivation and management, staff management, etc etc - is all done part-time, often at the end of the day, at night and at the weekend.

In a set of chambers, there are no billing targets to discount and so, if the member of the management committee, Head of Chambers or Chair of the management committee (assuming there is one) do not want to see a reduction in their own incomes, the situation is the same.

This has meant that for far too long, legal organisations were often run by enthusiastic amateurs. Some of these people have an extraordinary talent for management and so some firms have been able to perform very well. It is, however, too much to expect that someone will be an expert in their field, attracting high quality clients and high paying cases and that they will be an expert in business management.

Most law firms start to notice this problem as they get bigger and the management problems increase. They are often forced to 'outsource' some of the management of the firm to a professional manager - although that can lead to communication and expectation difficulties.

In this current and very difficult market for the law, the need for professionals has never been greater. More direct and public access means that members of chambers and clerks are suddenly dealing with a type of client with whom they are unfamiliar and who has a completely different set of requirements. Professional clients in law firms now have marketing teams who expect to be able to talk with their peers. Professional marketing from one part of the profession needs to be answered with professional marketing. Homely and home-made will no longer work.

It's not just marketing. With the importance of IT, more and more firms - and more and more chambers - have noticed how little they can get done if their systems aren't working. It's all very well to go for a fully hosted solution, but you still need to have someone on-site who is knowledgeable and who can translate what the 'techie' has said the problem is - and who can switch the router back on when someone accidentally switches it off, thereby saving the cost of an engineer's visit and (more importantly) about 2 hours.

The timescales have reduced. Clients expect emails answered immediately; twitter messages need to be dealt with in minutes sometimes; IT problems have to be resolved as soon as possible. I remember the days of the five day turnaround to answer a letter - but they have long gone. Staff problems will not wait for the next meeting of the management committee.

Professional management is also required. Unless you are trained and experienced in staff management, the chance of making a huge and eventually expensive error are high. Chambers and law firms need to have someone who can spend all their time getting the business to run better, making sure that the staff are motivated and know what they should be doing to support the strategy. The other professionals need to be managed by someone who knows what they are doing and makes the time to do it - and the legal professionals need to be released to do what they do well.

Clients don't want to have part-time and amateur legal advice - why should solicitors and barristers have to put up with poor support. The days of the amateur are over - long live the professional.

Wednesday, 2 September 2009

Stating the Bleeding Obvious

I remember being told many years ago, by one of the line managers I respected the most, that "the difficulty with the bleeding obvious is that it does need to be stated".

This phrase has never been truer than in the days of layoffs. Surely we all know that it can be incredibly expensive to lay staff off - and yet it sometimes appears that it is the first line of defence in some companies (and many law firms). Consider this post from the "Director Magazine" - the in-house publication from the Institute of Directors. Called "Think before you fire" it reminds us of the drawbacks to firing staff which I summarise here:
  1. Increased cost
  2. Lower productivity
  3. Brand damage
  4. Damage to leadership reputation
  5. More claims from remaining staff
The article goes into more detail, obviously, but it's not rocket science is it? Surely we all know this stuff? And yet...

There are a number of reasons that it goes on - and why it probably shouldn't:
  1. Many organisations have gained "slack" in their headcount - those people who are not performing, but who have been just a little too tricky to move out. In this economy, the pain is, perhaps, worth it. Think how much the firm would have saved, however, if they have been management properly all along.
  2. It is a very visible expression of management action. "Look!" say the Board "See what we are doing to improve PEP this year. We are cutting costs!". Cutting costs - really? This year costs will be high because of redundancy payments and associated costs, and next year costs will be high because of recruitment fees.
  3. It's something that people with limited management experience and knowledge understand. Well yes - but that doesn't make it the right thing to do. As far as cooking is concerned, I basically understand two dishes and know the number for pizza delivery off by heart - that doesn't make it a good diet, though. Good management is available to every firm. Hire professionals to do the job - not enthusiastic amateurs.
Perhaps this will define the next stage of my career - stating the bleeding obvious...

Friday, 28 August 2009

Lessons from the Apple Store

On the back of the report in the "London Evening Standard" (see here for the copy), in which it declares the Apple Store in Regent Street to be the most profitable shop in London at £2,000 per square foot, I was thinking about why this is and what lessons can be learnt.

Anyone who knows me will already be rolling their eyes and saying "Apple people..." with a sigh. I admit that I am an Apple user and a great fan. Apple have, however, taken a new route in their high street shops and one which would appear to be working.

The difference is customer focus. Give people a chance to see and use the Apple equipment, so the theory goes, and they will embrace it - and, more importantly, buy it. First of all it doesn't look particularly like a shop and has plenty of helpers at the front doors to engage with anyone needing guidance. In depth knowledge and help is available throughout the shop. Free seminars are put on all day, every day, to introduce the Apple software to both new and experienced users. Visitors - and a great number of people who come into the shop do not buy anything (this time) - are made welcome and can use any computer to access the internet or make use of the free wifi throughout the store. Above all, they have knowledgeable and committed staff working there who are trying to help customers and who are quite happy to say "I don't know" to a question - but immediately find another member of the team who can provide answers.

Of course it is easier for Apple than for other computer or software sellers since they control both hardware and software - but I think their real secret is to make a visit to the Apple store to be a pleasurable activity.

How many other businesses are there that do that - whether businesses that we work for or businesses that we consult to? How many of our customers would consider dealing with our firm as a pleasurable activity?

As in retail, so in professional services. Provide an excellent service, have committed and knowledgeable staff, and keep the needs, requirements and preferences of the clients at the forefront of all decisions. Simple!

Friday, 3 July 2009

Leadership & Ownership vs. Management in Law Firms

I have just read "Dealing With the 'Leadership Vacuum' in Law Firm Management" by Joel A. Rose.

In general I like the article since it speaks well about the tasks required to lead a firm. Where I differ is in the tasks he seems to allocate to the Senior/Managing Partner. Let me just quite one of his lists:
The following are some of the functions that the managing partner should perform:
  1. Maintaining the morale of the lawyers, as a group and individually.
  2. Anticipating management needs and making recommendations for fulfilling them.
  3. Supervising the administrator.
  4. Making decisions concerning matters that do not warrant consideration by the management committee, such as implementation of personnel policy.
  5. Implementing the management committee's decisions by informing the proper attorneys and by following up to see that the decisions have been implemented.
  6. Coordinating all management activities.
Ok - point 1 is well made and is one of the most important tasks for a Managing Partner. Point 2 - well, yes, but not on his/her own. The firm's management must be trusted to bring these things to the managing committee or Partner early enough too. Point 3 is a "no brainer". It's the rest I have serious problems about.

"Implementation of ... policy". That's why the firm should have professional managers. Note that I say "professional" - not lawyers performing the roles. In my experience, lawyers should not get very close to the implementation of any policy. Point 5 I could be persuaded about so long as we are talking about legal work. Point 6, though, really upsets me. Point 6 lies at the heart of many of the problems facing law firms. Coordination of management activities is an activity that should be performed by the Chief Executive or Chief Operating Officer - i.e. the non-lawyer who, operationally, runs the firm. This role can almost never be properly accomplished by a lawyer, unless they have (a) given up all legal work to concentrate on administration and (b) undertaken a good amount of education in management. Failing that a professional is needed. Someone with the knowledge, skills and experience to run the firm's administration while the lawyers do what they specialise in.

At the heart of this matter is often confusion amongst the Partners about the difference between ownership and management. I have often heard Partners saying "We own the firm and so want to be involved in the way it runs". Well, yes they do own the firm, but the only involvement in running the firm should be in the selection of a Chief Executive and setting strategy. Anything else is inefficient. Allow the lawyers to practice law and work with clients, allow the Managing Partner to run the lawyers and lead the firm, and allow the firm's management to get on an manage.