Showing posts with label Long Term. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Long Term. Show all posts

Wednesday, 21 November 2012

In Defence of the Merger?

I wrote recently about the problem of mergers in the legal market. My post seemed to resonate with a lot of people - it has been one of the most read articles on my blog with over 300 hits since it was published.

I have received a few comments about it too - most have been supportive, but a few have been critical - saying that I had underestimated the success of mergers and that I didn't quite understand the motivation behind firms merging.  In particular, it was suggested that I didn't understand the financial pressure to merge faced by smaller firms with no access to loan capital. So I have been reading around the subject today to see if I have been missing something.

I read a very interesting article from Syscap (see the article here), who are a 'provider of smart, cost-effective finance solutions' according to their web site. The article from Philip White, their CEO, suggests that since access to finance has become so difficult for smaller law firms, their only solution is a merger.

Even firms that can get offers of conventional bank loans are finding that those loans are too expensive. Bank of England data shows that lending margins for small businesses loans across all sectors are still on the rise.  Small businesses, such as sole practitioner law firms, are now paying the highest interest margins in three years on loans of less than £1 million. 
The law firms that Syscap speaks to about funding for tax payments, IT investment etc, leave us in little doubt that they are finding it almost impossible to get sensibly priced funding elsewhere in the market. 
Further evidence of how tough things are can be seen in the 17% jump, since the start of the year, in the number of funding requests that we have received from law firms to help pay their big semi-annual tax payments to HMRC.

The above quote form the article does demonstrate the difficulty of financing a firm - but I'm still not convinced that merging is the solution. Two smaller firms who can't finance a capital programme merge - and become a larger firm with the same problem.

Partnerships have always had some difficulty to get bank loans - there is almost no collateral for banks to lend against. The traditional answer to that problem has been the equity call - or rather the practice of retaining sufficient profit each year to fund capital projects, rather than returning as much as possible to the partners in order to boost that favourite measurement of Profit per Equity Partner (PEP). Recently, however the drive to show more profits being given to partners has meant that a smaller and smaller percentage has been retained within the firm.

I appreciate that the profits in small law firms are proportionately small - however their access to affordable finance is unlikely to improve in the near future (and I don't plan to get into the argument about non-partner equity here) and so partners will need to look at improving the profitability of the work that they do. Not so that they can take more out of the firm - but rather so that the partners can use the cash in the firm to fund efficiency projects and some real growth.

So - before you consider a merger consider this: look at the way that your firm works and the cases and matters it takes on. Increase the profitability of the work - don't just look for turnover. Talk with the partners about the large/capital projects required - whether that is investment in technology or a marketing push. Look to invest internally. Look to flatten out the peaks and troughs that normally categorise partner drawings by developing a long-term financing strategy based on internal investment and a longer equity return model.

It's not likely to be a particularly popular strategy (particularly with those senior partners about to retire and withdrawn their equity) - but it will provide some stability to the firm and a platform for growth.

Tuesday, 7 September 2010

New Term - New Report

"The Lawyer" has just released it's "UK 200 Annual Report 2010" (which is available online here). It is interesting reading. There are a number of claims about new measurements - but the focus on revenue remains as does the industry's fascination with PEP.

I encourage you to have a thorough read of the report. What the suggests is that, by adopting new scales such as "Days to Profit" (on page 6 of the report), the magazine is keen to try to reduce the "gaming" of statistics that goes on. For example - an easy way to increase PEP is to reduce the number of applicable equity partners - something a number of the top firms have done. It's certainly easier (if perhaps more expensive in the long run) than trying to increase profit.

While the "Days to Profit" is interesting, I was more taken by the table on page 8 of the report showing the top firms by cost reduction. The report orders the firms by the size of the one-year reduction from last year to this, but for me the interesting numbers are those in the five-year difference in costs. The leading "one-year-cutter" is Freshfields who have cut their costs by 19.3% in one year. Without more detail I can't comment on the efficacy or long-term effect of this size of cuts, but it is, I will guess, related more to the booking of redundancy costs in the previous year than to anything else. Over the last five years, Freshfields have increased their costs by 22.93% which doesn't seem too bad. Hammonds show a five-year change of -5.9%, although I'm not sure I'd use Hammonds as s good example. Wragge & Co show restraint with a five-year increase of less than 10%. These longer period measurements are more useful because they avoid the peaks and troughs of "spend and cut" than tend to characterise the industry.

The tope four firms are analysed in some depth and their performance examined over five years, but with the rest of the firms in the listing, it is business as usual in terms of focussing on turnover, PEP and figures for a single year.

Surely if there is one thing that the last two years have taught us, it is that looking at performance for one year is now use at all in terms of examining the success of a firm. I look forward to the day when firms are ranked by their rolling five-year net profit, amongst other longer-term measurements.

Still - small steps, and the new measurements are better than before.

From the report, my highlights are:

  • Barlow, Lyde and Gilbert for strong five-year cost reduction
  • Beachcroft and Wragge & Co for doing well on the "Cost per Lawyer" category
  • Dickson Minto for achieving 7th place in the "Revenue per Partner" list and performing well again in the "revenue per Lawyer" category
  • Sacker & Partners for achieving 7th place in "Revenue per Lawyer"

Wednesday, 4 November 2009

When is a Law Firm like a Football Club?

Any regular readers will know that I am passionate about moving law firms (well actually any firm) away from too much short term thinking.

Listening to the news today, it occurred to me that managing a law firm must be a little like managing a football club. Only a very few football managers are given much time to produce results and almost every manager is judged over an incredibly short period. This morning's news item was in connection with Liverpool FC who, apparently, have lost 6 of their last 7 games. They play again this evening and the report stated that a poor result might cost the manager his job. Notwithstanding the media's need for catastrophe, it does underline the "results now" nature of football management.  The six matches from 29th August were all won and included a 6-1 win against Hull. The one win in the last 7 matches was against Manchester United. So is this really the sort of performance that should require the termination of the manager's contract?

This sort of attitude reminds me of law firms. Performance is (rightly) reported monthly to the partners - but this can mean that time frame for decisions is much much shorter than it should be. One month of bad results, and partners can be demanding that "something must be done" and ordering management to turn around the firm's performance.


Both types of organisation would do better to expand their view so that they can properly analyse short term performance in a longer context. I remember talking with a law partner who spent the first 10 minutes telling me how worried he was that the recently released figures for the preceding month were poor. He was very concerned and had asked the Managing Partner what new cost-cutting measures could be implemented. I asked what the results were for that month in the previous years, and he did not know. I called him the day after our meeting, however, and he had found out that the month in question was a bad month every year - and in fact that this year had been less bad than usual. He had to admit, however, that he had not gone back to the Managing Partner to say that further cost cuts were not necessary...

One other similarity between law firms and football clubs struck me. Both are organisations built around highly trained specialists. Both have a fair number of prima-donnas. And in case of poor performance it is often the second-string team, management, and support team who suffer the consequences. Have you ever heard of a football club sacking first team players because of a string of 6 losses - I certainly never have.

My point? Short term results must be viewed in context. Medium and longer term results are usually better indications of the true performance of the organisation. Make sure that you performance manage everyone - "stars" included. Poor results are as likely to be the result of poor performance as they are poor management.