Showing posts with label Budgets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Budgets. Show all posts

Monday, 12 October 2009

Confident Guessing

I read a story in "Legal Week" today which said that "Law firm business confidence has recovered for the second quarter in a row with more than half of partners now expecting revenue growth at their own firms over the next 12 months" - see the full story here.

Hmm. I would love the economy to recover and would be delighted to hear that the majority of partners were expecting growth - if I really thought that some analysis and research had gone into the partners' statements. Sadly I suspect that the same level of care will have gone into these announcements as went into planning for this year's budget in most firms.

I spoke with a number of firms, large and small, as they developed and then started to work on new budgets. The development process in law firms is not the same, boring, routine used in most commercial organisations. Analysis of past expenditure together with a detailed study of the requirements for the next period are undertaken, but are generally overtaken by "gut feel". I was astonished to watch large companies set a budgeted revenue figure based on "assessments" by the department heads - assessments which had no scientific basis and which had often been arrived at following an evening's worth of discussion between the partner leading the department and his team (occasionally I saw the team discussion phase ignored as unnecessary). The accounting staff were not called on for input and it was rare for the marketing or business development team to be asked for their help. I saw firms forecast 25%, 30% and 40% drops in revenue based on a personal assessment of "difficult times".

I would have been less concerned with this had it not led to a desire to see a similar drop on the expenditure side of the budget. "My goodness" the partners would say, "our revenue is dreadful - we will have to cut, cut, cut!", and expenditure budgets would be savaged - capital projects cut, staff cut and day-to-day expenditure on small items cut "to show willing."

Now, less that 12 months on, "confidence is high" apparently. That's fine for the revenue side of the equation - the firm will just exceed budget. What about all the people who have been removed, however? What about the hiatus in capital projects? My perception is that the same partners who made short-term, knee-jerk, decisions for this budget year have now got bored with the whole "downturn thing" and, finding that their own forecasts have been hopelessly pessimistic have decided that everything will now be fine and are confident that their revenue, and so their profit, will soon recover.

They were wrong before and they may be wrong now. Some forecasters will undoubtedly be speaking from a position of strength - they will have done the analysis required to be confident that their assessments are sensible. Most partners, sadly, will not. At the very least, the economy will be different and the "playing field" changed. If partners believe that, having weathered the downturn they now need only weather the recovery (for a maximum of another 12 months) before returning to business as before, they will be sadly mistaken. Clients have been given power and will be reluctant to give it back. Hourly rates are under attack as never before, and few firms have a sensible defence for them. More importantly, those running law firms have been exposed as never before. It is becoming apparent that few law firms are run in a business-like manner and clients are starting to ask why they should pay for this inefficiency.

I'm glad that confidence is returning to the sector - but will be more glad when that confidence has a sound basis. I'll wait to hear from those members of the profession that I know and trust before I too relax into confidence.

Monday, 20 July 2009

Leave the Analysis for the Experts

My colleague, James Dunning, suggested that I should look into (again) the way that the Swine Flu issue is being reported. In examining the way that the reporting is being done, I'm very grateful to Ben Goldacre who has a long running campaign against poor reporting of statistics in the press.

This week, the UK press has been obsessed with the figure of 65,000 deaths from swine flu. An article in the "Guardian" gives a wonderful example of how the figures have been used by journalists who either do not understand statistics or who don't care in the face of a good story. I really do recommend the story as a case study in the use of statistics.

There is a wider point to be made, I believe. The "Guardian" story shows the importance of using experts - or at least using people who understand the data. Sadly many businesses - and in my experience, most law firms - have the same "good enough" attitude to their own financial reporting, and certainly to their budgeting. A straw poll of law firms (well the four who answered my questions on the understanding that they would not be identified) showed that all of them were going to budget for a substantial reduction in revenue for the 2009/2010 budget year. Well that sounds quite sensible, so far. The range of reductions was from 10% to 30%.

Let me just emphasise that - one firm was budgeting for a 30% drop in revenue. One of my posts earlier last week shows an average of 2.8% increase in revenue for a sample of firms between 2007/2008 and 2008/2009. None of the firms I polled were able to provide any data or sensible explanation for the reduction they proposed.

This is the law firm equivalent of the tabloid press shouting "65,000 deaths!". The various finance committees or boards (or whoever decides these things) seem to have noticed there was a downturn and decided that their business would almost disappear. One firm was willing to speak anonymously in detail. This firm was looking at a budget of 25% less revenue - in the face of proposals from the business units which showed a maximum of 10% reduction.

Data is very useful - firms should have as much useful data as possible. It is vital, however, that the analysis is done by someone who understands what data means; who understand caveats about statistical significance; and who can explain what the data actually means to non-experts. This is vital to both law firms and the tabloid press.